Repairing Car Accident Deformation: Cut and Replace or Sheet Metal? Which Restores the Vehicle to its Original State?

When it comes to car repairs, there are two main options: using sheet metal or cutting and replacing parts. Many car owners don’t think much about this, especially when insurance covers the repairs and repair shops offer various solutions. The decision to use sheet metal or cutting and replacing parts is often influenced by insurance companies trying to minimize costs during their assessment.

Repair shops propose solutions based on convenience, leaving many car owners confused about what’s best for their vehicles. When insurance companies assess the damage from an accident, additional repair items may be added to address hidden issues not identified in the initial evaluation.

Insurance companies are strict about sheet metal parts and recommend it if the cost is not significantly higher than cutting and replacing parts. Regardless of repair technicians’ skills, they will choose the method that suits them best.

For areas with minimal deformation and no distortions at the edges, sheet metal is a viable option, although its surface may not be perfectly smooth after processing, requiring additional work with putty to achieve a flawless finish. Cutting and replacing parts involve addressing only the welded portions, as new parts are stamped and relatively smooth. While this method is more expensive, it ensures the overall performance of the vehicle.

Both repair methods are effective for cars, provided that repair quality is guaranteed based on workmanship, materials, and the quality of replacement parts. It is advisable to consider individual circumstances and choose accordingly. For moderately damaged cars, it’s recommended to prioritize larger repair shops over smaller ones, as they have better equipment and can ensure the availability of quality parts.